Payslip44 vs FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker
FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker is a free stub and invoice maker from WebbyGenius. See how it compares with Payslip44 on tax math, exports, and pricing.
Disclosure: Payslip44 is our app. This comparison is written honestly, including the places where FreePayStub Now is the better fit. Ratings, features, and pricing come from the US App Store and Google Play listings as of September 2026.
Quick answer
FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker by WebbyGenius Infotech Private Limited, listed on Google Play under the one-word spelling FreePayStubNow, has been on the App Store since 2023, with 4.69 from 195 US ratings. It generates a stub and does the deduction math for you. It also bundles an invoice generator. Apple lists no in-app purchases for it, so per its listing the whole app is free.
Payslip44 builds a pay stub line by line from figures you enter: earnings, deductions, employer contributions, leave balances, and year-to-date totals, in six layouts, exported as PDF, image, CSV, or text. It is free to download and works offline. No account needed.
If you want the app to work out the deductions for you and you want to pay nothing, FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker. If you need a stub that states the worker’s classification and carries YTD, leave, and payment detail, Payslip44.
Side-by-side
| Feature | Payslip44 | FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | iOS + Android | iOS + Android |
| US App Store rating | 5.00 (1 rating) | 4.69 (195 ratings) |
| Last updated | August 2026 | August 2026 |
| Free-tier limits | Not stated | No stated limit; the listing says the app is free to use “as much as you want” |
| Paid plans | Pro $2.99 a week or $29.99 a year, after a 7-day free trial | None listed on the App Store |
| Build and export a pay stub | Yes | Yes |
| Calculates taxes for you | No, figures are user-entered | Yes, claimed; no tax year or states named |
| W-2, 1099, statutory, owner classifications | Yes | Not stated |
| Year-to-date totals | Yes | Not stated |
| Employer contributions | Yes, 401(k) match and insurance | Not stated |
| Saved employers and employees | Yes, reusable on the next stub | Not stated |
| Document layouts | Yes, six | Yes, count not stated |
| Custom logo on the stub | Yes, in the employer header | Yes |
| Invoice generator | Not stated | Yes |
| Multiple jobs / profiles | Yes, via saved employers and employees | Not stated |
| Export | PDF, image, CSV, text | Download or email; no file format named |
| Languages | 1 (English) | 1 (English) |
| Ads | No | No per its listing |
| Account required | No | Not stated |
| Data stays on device | Yes, no account, works offline | Not stated |
| Privacy label | Data Not Linked to You: Purchases, Identifiers, Usage Data, Diagnostics; declares no data used to track you | Data Not Collected |
Where FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker wins
Nothing to buy through the App Store. Apple lists no in-app purchases for it, and Google Play shows none either. The description repeats the free claim in bullet after bullet and says the preview step costs nothing extra. Payslip44 is free to download but sells a Pro subscription at $2.99 a week or $29.99 a year, so if your budget for this is zero, that is a real difference.
It does the deduction math. Its listing says the generator “will automatically perform its calculations, so you don’t need to worry about calculating deductions and other complicated calculations”, and it claims tax calculations as well. Payslip44 states the opposite: it does not calculate taxes or withholding, and every figure on the stub is one you entered. But FreePayStub Now’s listing never names a tax year or a state, and never says whether it covers federal and state. So you cannot tell from the store page how current those calculations are. One reviewer notes not being able to customize state.
Invoices and Canada stubs in the same app. It includes an invoice generator with customizable templates, and the listing says Canadian users can generate Canada pay stubs alongside those invoices. Payslip44’s listing mentions neither. If you send invoices and stubs from the same phone, that is one app instead of two.
A longer track record and far more ratings. It has been on the App Store since December 2023 and is now on version 3.0.1. It has 4.69 from 195 US ratings. Payslip44 launched in June 2026 and has a single App Store rating, which tells you nothing either way. On Google Play the picture reverses: FreePayStub Now has 3.4 from 82 reviews.
Where Payslip44 wins
The stub says who the worker is. Payslip44 marks each person as a W-2 employee, 1099 contractor, statutory employee, or owner. It records employer contributions such as a 401(k) match or insurance. FreePayStub Now’s listing names independent contractors as an audience but never mentions a classification, so the stub structure is not stated.
Every line the stub needs. Earnings by hours and rate or a flat amount, taxable flags, pre-tax deductions like 401(k), HSA, and health insurance, after-tax items like garnishments and union dues, year-to-date totals, leave balances with accrued, used, and remaining hours, and the payment method down to the check number or the last four digits of the account. None of that is stated on FreePayStub Now’s listing.
You know what file you get. Payslip44 exports as PDF, image, CSV, or text, in six layouts, and the A4 preview you see is the file you export. FreePayStub Now says you can download the stub or have it emailed to you, but names no format anywhere on the listing.
It works offline with no account. Payslip44 says it needs no account and runs completely offline. Your data stays on the device, and there are no ads. FreePayStub Now’s listing does not state whether an account is needed or whether generation happens on your phone; its “submit” and “email it to your mailbox” wording points the other way.
Pricing
- Payslip44 is free to download, with no ads and no account. Pro is $2.99 a week or $29.99 a year after a 7-day free trial.
- FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker by WebbyGenius Infotech Private Limited is free, with no in-app purchases listed on either store and no tier named in the description. One reviewer notes a $9 charge at the download step, which no store source confirms.
A year of Payslip44 Pro is $29.99 at the annual price, or $155.48 if you pay weekly. A year of FreePayStub Now costs nothing on the App Store, which is the strongest thing on its side of this page.
Which one should you pick?
Pick FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker if you want the app to work out the deductions or you want an invoice generator in the same place. It is also the pick if you want to pay nothing at all. Note that its App Store seller URL is stubcreator.com and its Play listing is published under the developer name Online Paystub, the same domain and name that sit behind StubCreator: Paystub Generator in our roundup of paystub generator apps.
Pick Payslip44 if the stub has to state a worker classification, carry YTD and leave balances, name the payment method, and come out as a PDF, image, CSV, or text file. Same if you would rather the app never ask for an account.
If you need the numbers before you build the stub, our free FICA tax calculator and YTD earnings calculator run in the browser with no download.
Frequently asked questions
Is FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker actually free?
Per its App Store listing, yes. Apple lists no in-app purchases for it, and the description calls the app free in bullet after bullet; the preview step costs nothing extra. One reviewer notes being asked for $9 at the download step, but that is a single review from 2024 and no store source confirms it. Payslip44 is free to download, with Pro at $2.99 a week or $29.99 a year after a 7-day free trial.
Does Payslip44 calculate taxes and withholding?
No. Payslip44's listing states plainly that it does not calculate taxes or withholding and is not financial, payroll, or tax advice. You enter the figures and it formats them to the exact cent. FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker claims automatic deductions and tax calculations, but its listing does not name a tax year, a state, or whether federal and state are both covered.
Which one handles 1099 contractors?
Payslip44 lets you mark a worker as W-2, 1099 contractor, statutory employee, or owner. FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker names independent contractors as an audience in its description, but the listing never mentions 1099, W-2, or any worker classification, so that is not stated.
Can I use either app offline or without an account?
Payslip44 says it needs no account and works completely offline, with your data kept on the device. FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker does not state either way; its description talks about submitting a stub and emailing it to your mailbox, so do not assume offline use.
What file formats can each app export?
Payslip44 exports a stub as PDF, image, CSV, or text. FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker says you can download a stub or email it to yourself, but names no file format anywhere on its listing.
Which app has more App Store ratings?
FreePayStub Now: Paystub Maker, by a wide margin. As of September 2026 it holds 4.69 from 195 US ratings, while Payslip44 shows 5.00 from a single rating because it launched in June 2026. On Google Play the order flips: 3.4 from 82 reviews against Payslip44's 4.7.